Individual Justice and International Guidance – When Every Voice Matters
Part of the CERD Awareness Series
Racial discrimination is not just a policy issue: it is a lived experience, a moment that can leave someone feeling isolated, unheard, or invisible. Articles 14 and 15 of CERD recognise this reality. They shift the conversation from national obligations to individual human beings, ensuring that no one is left behind when systems fail.
Together, these Articles amplify one essential truth:
Human rights mean nothing if the people they are meant to protect cannot use them.
For Scotland’s ethnic minority communities who continue to face barriers in employment, policing, housing, education, and everyday life this principle is deeply relevant. Justice must be accessible, trusted, and real.
Article 14: When the System Fails, the Individual Must Still Be Heard
Article 14 allows individuals to bring a complaint of racial discrimination directly to the CERD Committee but only if their government recognises this procedure. It creates a safety net for people whose experiences of racism have been ignored, mishandled, or dismissed at home.
For many people in Scotland especially asylum seekers, migrant workers, Roma communities, and people of African descent this matters deeply. When someone has exhausted local remedies but still feels unheard, Article 14 says: you are not out of options.
Imagine a community member in Scotland repeatedly reporting racial harassment in their housing block. Despite clear evidence, nothing changes. The landlord denies responsibility, the complaints process drags on, and the individual feels trapped.
Under Article 14 (if fully activated), that person could take their case to an international body that is independent, impartial, and obligated to listen.
It shifts the narrative from “no one will hear me” to “there is still a path to justice.”
Article 15: When Countries Learn from Each Other, Communities Benefit
Article 15 focuses on States with special commitments or obligations, ensuring that international oversight applies consistently, even where historical or political arrangements exist.
In practice, this keeps all States accountable-no exceptions, no loopholes. This is not about criticism. It is about collaboration, learning, and growth.
Why this matters in Scotland
When the CERD Committee reviews the UK, it highlights both strengths and gaps. These recommendations speak directly to issues Scotland recognises:
- racial disparities in school exclusions,
- concerns about policing and stop-and-search,
- barriers to employment and promotion,
- inequalities in health outcomes,
- challenges faced by asylum seekers and migrants,
- underrepresentation in leadership and decision-making.
These are not distant problems; they are the lived realities of many people here. For communities in Scotland who often feel power imbalances such as refugees navigating the asylum process or minority workers facing discriminatory environments Articles 14 and 15 reinforce that justice should never depend on geography or political willingness alone.
Reflection: Human Rights Begin with Human Stories
The beauty of Articles 14 and 15 is that they centre the human being. They honour the lived reality behind each statistic, each policy, each recommendation.
They remind us that every person in Scotland from asylum seekers in temporary accommodation, to long-established Black and Asian communities, to newly arrived migrant workers deserves systems that see them, hear them, and protect them.
At BEMIS Scotland, this is at the heart of our mission: to ensure ethnic minority communities understand their rights and can use them confidently, safely, and without fear.
⚖️ CERD in Scotland: From Commitment to Action
#CERDSeries #HumanRightsInPractice #RacialEqualityScotland #AccessToJustice #InclusionMatters #BEMISScotland #CommunityVoices #AntiRacism #EqualityForAll #FromCommitmentToAction #ScotlandForAll